Latino Group Calls on U.S. Attorney to Expand Tenet Healthcare Probe

Embattled Hospital Giant Faces Harsh Criticism about Medicaid DSH Funds and Mistreatment of Uninsured

EAST LOS ANGELES, Calif., Nov 1, 2002 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- After a federal raid at a Tenet Healthcare hospital (THC) in California, K.B. Forbes, Executive Director of Consejo de Latinos Unidos, a national non-profit organization that aids and assists Hispanics, sent a letter this morning requesting that U.S. Attorney John K. Vincent expand his investigation into Tenet Healthcare's billing practices.

"We are requesting that you expand your probe into Tenet Healthcare's billing practices. Tenet appears to be using the uninsured to game the system. The name of Tenet's game is Medicaid DSH (Disproportionate Share Reimbursement program)," writes Forbes. "The U.S. Department of Justice has been very successful in investigating Medicare fraud. We now ask that you turn your attention to Tenet and the Medicaid DSH program. Our advocacy group is gravely concerned about how deplorable Tenet Healthcare has mistreated the uninsured. The reason seems to us to be a grab for federal dollars."

In his letter, Forbes alleges that uninsured people who went to a Tenet hospital appear to have been overcharged and then forced not to pay. Recalling events from last year, Forbes writes, "It appears no payment plans were offered and an 'all-or-nothing' collection approach was used. Obviously, these people could not pay the lump sum. We were stumped by Tenet's alleged behavior. Why would a hospital refuse to accept payment plans? What was the motive to collect nothing instead of something? We then learned about the lucrative Medicaid DSH program for hospitals."

After reviewing the Medicaid DSH formulas, Forbes writes, "we concluded that bad debts were needed to retain the federal DSH funds ... In California, Tenet has been aggressive in demonstrating bad debt. In a one-year period, Tenet obtained over 400 collection judgments totaling over $1.6 million." He adds, "We were surprised to hear that the State of California does not contact uninsured patients who were ... listed as a bad debt. Were the procedures necessary? Are the bills accurate? Does anyone know if these uninsured people are alive and well?"

The Consejo letter concludes, "Since you and your office have uncovered some serious allegations of fraud against Medicare patients, is it not wise to expand your investigation to include Medicaid billing practices and take a look at what is being done to the uninsured population? We think so."

The Consejo has objected to Tenet's treatment of the uninsured. Since June, Tenet's attempt to purchase a five-hospital chain in San Antonio and Tenet's billion-dollar proposal in Kansas City were scrutinized over alleged mistreatment of the uninsured. Tenet lost both deals.

SOURCE Consejo de Latinos Unidos 
Brad Hoffman of the Consejo de Latinos Unidos, +1-626-644-2273